This in vitro pilot study was performed to determine whether a treatment algorithm including mechanical debridement, followed by air powder abrasion with glycine, followed by citric acid conditioning with vigorous flushing of the surface with sterile water after each step, is capable of decontaminating an infected implant surface. A total of 14 dental implants that were deemed hopeless due to advanced peri-implantitis were extracted. Of these, 6 implants served as tests and had their exposed surfaces treated with the decontamination protocol, 6 served as untreated controls, and 2 were mechanically treated only, followed by rubbing the surface with sterile saline. All implants were placed in culture with human osteoprogenitor cells for 72 hours, and evaluation was performed using scanning electron microscopy. The 6 test implants all demonstrated attachment and proliferation of the normal human osteoprogenitor cells on their prior exposed and decontaminated surfaces. All of the untreated control and the mechanically debrided, sterile water-treated implants failed to demonstrate this same success. The results suggest that this protocol can decontaminate an implant surface affected by peri-implantitis. Further studies are warranted to determine if this technique would demonstrate similar success over a greater number of implants and whether this outcome may occur in humans.